Insiders at COVID-19 vaccine makers sold nearly $500M of stock last year
What’s holding back a faster vaccine rollout?
Dr. Alexander Garza of the St. Louis Metropolitan Pandemic Task Force on reopening schools, new coronavirus variants and the vaccine rollout, which he says is being slowed down by the manufacturing process.
Executives and directors at Pfizer Inc., Moderna Inc. and other companies developing Covid-19 vaccines sold approximately $496 million of stock last year, reaping rewards of positive vaccine developments that drove up the value of the drugmakers’ shares.
Continue Reading Below
Executives and directors at the same 13 companies sold about $132 million of stock in 2019, according to insider transaction data from research firm Kaleidoscope. More than 8.5 million shares were sold last year by insiders at these companies, compared with 4.7 million shares in 2019.
In dollar terms, much of the sales came at a single company, Moderna, maker of one of two Covid-19 vaccines authorized for use in the U.S. Executives and a director there sold more than $321 million of their stock in more than 700 transactions. Merck & Co. insiders sold $58 million of their shares. At Novavax Inc., executives sold more than $40 million of their shares after the company’s vaccine hit milestones in August and September.
COVID-19 VACCINE APPROVAL PROCESS: DOES IT TAKE TOO LONG?
Merck, which last May said it was pursuing two vaccines, scrapped those efforts last month after data showed disappointing immune responses. Novavax announced positive results of its clinical trials last month.
Some of the sales toward the end of last year have drawn the attention of government officials, with the then-head of the Securities and Exchange Commission calling for new restrictions on the trading plans under which many of the sales were made.
Corporate compensation experts say these kinds of sales are the natural consequence of a long-term shift to using stock for a greater share of executive pay, with the goal being to tie pay to performance—in this case the development of life-saving vaccines. Top company officials, like other investors, may be disinclined to leave profits on the table, as long as they adhere to insider-trading rules, some consultants say.
“This is behavior that I would expect to see in most of these companies,” said Ben Silverman, director of research at InsiderScore, which analyzes transactions by corporate insiders. While Mr. Silverman described some of the selling as aggressive, he said it isn’t unusual, particularly for young companies like Moderna whose executives have seen the value of their holdings jump dramatically.
Some of the selling was part of preset trading plans that were established before the pandemic. The rest was mostly part of preset trading plans that were changed or adopted after vaccine development was under way. Those changes allowed for more selling in the second half of the year when positive news about the vaccines was coming out.
CHALLENGES TO COVID-19 LOCKDOWNS HAVE BEEN MOSTLY LOSING IN COURT
Preset trading plans often are set up to allow officers who might have access to nonpublic information to sell shares without exposing themselves to charges of insider trading. The so-called 10b5-1 plans can set prices or other thresholds that trigger automatic sales when reached. Some plans require a “cooling-off period” between the time the plan is implemented and the first trade.
Novavax said its executives adhere to the laws of company stock sales and have sold a fraction of their overall holdings in the company. Pfizer didn’t respond to requests for comment. Merck didn’t provide any comment.
Companies aren’t required to disclose these plans, though they often disclose when a transaction is tied to a plan in the interest of providing legal protection for the seller, said Mr. Silverman.
“As an investor, what you want to look out for is that opportunistic behavior where people are targeting specific prices, increasing the pace of selling at a higher price or these examples where there are significant changes in behavior,” he said.
Executives sell stock for a variety of reasons that can be unrelated to developments at their companies, including diversification, estate planning and setting aside money for college tuition.
At Moderna, 17% of the dollar amount of the transactions, or about $56 million, was part of 10b5-1 trading plans established before 2020 that weren’t updated last year, according to a Wall Street Journal analysis of securities filings. Some Moderna executives amended their 10b5-1 trading plans or established new ones in March, May and June of last year, after trials for the vaccine started and after the company received government funding to speed up its development.
A spokesman for Moderna said all executive sales are made under 10b5-1 trading plans. In August, executives and directors agreed not to enter into new plans, add shares to existing plans or engage in additional unscheduled sales, the spokesman said. In December, the company once again allowed trading through new or modified preset trading plans, following the disclosure of efficacy numbers for its Covid-19 vaccine.
GET FOX BUSINESS ON THE GO BY CLICKING HERE
Chief Executive Stéphane Bancel sold $98 million of his shares last year. He had been selling an average 86,000 shares a month last year until June, after which the pace of share sales doubled. Mr. Bancel’s sales represented less than 10% of his holdings, the company said.
In November, Pfizer CEO Albert Bourla sold about $5.6 million in company shares—about 60% of his holdings at the time—on the same day the company announced positive results from its Covid-19 vaccine, which the FDA authorized for emergency use in the U.S. in December. Pfizer said at the time that the sale was part of Mr. Bourla’s personal financial planning and relied on a 10b5-1 plan. Mr. Bourla authorized the sale in February 2020 and renewed the authorization in August with identical price and volume terms, the company said.
Big-ticket stock sales at Pfizer, Moderna and elsewhere have come under scrutiny from some investors and government officials. In November, the head of the SEC called for new restrictions on trading under these plans. “For senior executive officers using 10b5-1 plans to sell stock, I do believe that a cooling-off period from the time that the plan is put in place or is materially changed, until the first transaction, is appropriate,” then-SEC Chairman Jay Clayton said at a Senate hearing.
Merck Chairman and CEO Kenneth Frazier sold $23 million in stock in November, while the company’s vaccine candidate was in clinical trial. His trades weren’t attributed to a trading plan, unlike all of his other transactions since October 2015. The selloff represented 40% of his vested stock at the time.
CLICK HERE TO READ MORE ON FOX BUSINESS
Novavax executives sold $23 million of shares in August a day after the company announced the beginning of the second phase of its clinical trial. The August sales weren’t attributed to a trading plan in securities filings.
In late September, executives at Novavax sold another $19 million in shares days after entering phase three of the clinical trial for its vaccine candidate. Securities filings from the last week of September tied the sales to a trading plan but didn’t disclose when the plan was set up.
Moderna and Pfizer insiders who set up preset trading plans last year all had cooling-off periods of less than three months. Novavax insiders didn’t disclose dates for the adoption of their preset trading plans. Most of Merck insiders’ sales weren’t tied to such trading plans, and the ones that were didn’t include dates for the plans.
Moderna’s spokesman said the company requires that any new or revised 10b5-1 plans are subject to a significant cooling-off period before any transactions under those plans can be triggered, but didn’t say how long.
—Theo Francis contributed to this article.
Source: Read Full Article